Who Was Standing at Sinai When YHWH Spoke?

What Does the Text Actually Say?

Barn Scribe Opening

We have already seen that the children of Israel did not leave Egypt alone.

A mixed multitude went up with them.

That leaves us with a question we really cannot dodge if we are going to keep asking who is Israel?

Who was actually standing at Sinai when YHWH spoke?

I do not want to assume that everyone there was identified the same way, and I do not want to assume that everybody traveling with Israel somehow disappeared before they reached the mountain.

So we are going to slow this down and look at who Torah says was there.

Not who later tradition says was there.

Not who I think should have been there.

Who the text actually puts in front of us.

The Text

Exodus 19:1–8

“In the third month after the children of Israel were gone forth out of the land of Egypt, the same day came they into the wilderness of Sinai.

And when they were departed from Rephidim, and were come to the wilderness of Sinai, they encamped in the wilderness; and there Israel encamped before the mount.

And Moses went up unto God, and YHWH called unto him out of the mountain, saying: ‘Thus shalt thou say to the house of Jacob, and tell the children of Israel:

Ye have seen what I did unto the Egyptians, and how I bore you on eagles’ wings, and brought you unto Myself.

Now therefore, if ye will hearken unto My voice indeed, and keep My covenant, then ye shall be Mine own treasure from among all peoples; for all the earth is Mine;

and ye shall be unto Me a kingdom of priests, and a holy nation. These are the words which thou shalt speak unto the children of Israel.’

And Moses came and called for the elders of the people, and set before them all these words which YHWH commanded him.

And all the people answered together, and said: ‘All that YHWH hath spoken we will do.’ And Moses reported the words of the people unto YHWH.”

What Is Set Forward

What is sitting in front of us here is interesting because Torah uses several ways of speaking about the same gathering.

They are the children of Israel. They are Israel. YHWH tells Moses to speak to the house of Jacob and to the children of Israel. Then Moses comes down, speaks to the elders, and all the people answer together.

That is a lot of identity language packed into a very small space.

And because we already know from Exodus 12 that a mixed multitude came out of Egypt with the children of Israel, I do not think we should casually pretend that question has gone away.

At the same time, this passage does not stop and say, “Now let me explain exactly how every person standing here is classified.”

It simply addresses the gathering as Israel.

That is worth sitting with.

Especially because YHWH is not only speaking about ancestry here. He is speaking about hearing His voice, keeping His covenant, and becoming His treasured possession, a kingdom of priests, and a holy nation.

So the question in front of us is getting larger.

Not because we are making it larger.

Because the text is.

What Is Observed

What I keep coming back to here is how naturally Torah moves between house of Jacob, children of Israel, Israel, and all the people without stopping to explain every boundary for us.

That does not mean the words all mean exactly the same thing in every setting. I do not think we have earned that conclusion. But in this passage they are all sitting very close together, and that is hard to ignore.

We also have another piece already on the table from Exodus 12: a mixed multitude came out of Egypt with the children of Israel. Now at Sinai, Torah does not pause to tell us what happened to that group. It does not say they left. It does not say they were excluded. It simply keeps moving and speaks to the gathering before the mountain.

That is where I have to be careful.

I could start filling in the blanks from tradition, theology, or even my own assumptions. But the text has not done that yet.

What it has done is place a people before YHWH and connect that gathering with Jacob, Israel, covenant, obedience, and the words “all the people answered together.”

That gives us something to work with.

Not everything.

But something.

What Is Revealed

What this passage begins to show me is that the gathering at Sinai is not being described in one flat way.

Torah reaches backward to Jacob, speaks to the children of Israel, refers to Israel, and then tells us that all the people answered together.

That is where I have to resist the urge to tidy everything up too quickly.

The old preacher in me would love to put everybody in the proper box, label the box, underline it twice, and move on. But the text has not done that for me.

And honestly, I am beginning to appreciate that.

Because what YHWH is putting in front of the people is not merely a family tree. He is speaking about hearing His voice, keeping His covenant, and what they are to become before Him.

That does not erase ancestry. Jacob is still standing there in the language.

But covenant is now standing there too.

And the mixed multitude we already saw leaving Egypt has not been explained away for us. So I think we need to keep both things on the table and keep reading.

Maybe the next passage will clear it up.

Maybe it will make the question even bigger.

You’d think I’d learn not to predict which one Torah will do. 😄

What Is Established

At this point, I think we can establish something, but I also think the questions are getting better.

Torah brings us to Sinai and speaks to the gathering as the house of Jacob, the children of Israel, Israel, and all the people. We already know from the Exodus account that others came out of Egypt with the children of Israel, and this passage does not stop to sort everybody into neat categories for us.

That keeps me from making this simpler than the text does.

What YHWH does make plain is that the people standing there are being addressed in covenant terms. He speaks about hearing His voice, keeping His covenant, becoming His treasured possession, a kingdom of priests, and a holy nation.

So now the question “Who is Israel?” has more sitting under it than ancestry alone.

Not less than ancestry.

More.

And that is probably where some of our assumptions are going to start getting uncomfortable.

I can already feel the old preacher reaching for an answer, and for once I am going to let the question sit there and stare back at him.

We are not finished.

Not even close.

Barn Scribe Closing

We started this page with what looked like a fairly simple question: Who was standing at Sinai when YHWH spoke?

By now I think it is fair to say the question is not quite as simple as it looked.

Torah has brought Jacob’s name forward, called the people the children of Israel, spoken of Israel as a people, and then told us that all the people answered together. We also already know that a mixed multitude came out of Egypt with them.

Now, that does not give us permission to start filling in every blank.

But it does keep me from pretending there are no blanks.

And that may be the real value of slowing down like this.

The text is not asking us to force everybody into a system before we have finished reading. It is asking us to pay attention to who is there, how they are being addressed, and what YHWH is putting in front of them.

What I keep seeing is that ancestry has not disappeared, but neither has covenant.

Both are sitting in the same story.

That means our bigger question, “Who is Israel?”, is still very much alive.

And I am beginning to think the safest thing we can do is stop trying to answer it too quickly.

Well, that gives an old fellow something to chew on.

We are not done.

We are just finally asking the question slowly enough to hear what the text may be saying.

Turn the page. ☕📜