What Makes Israel a Great Nation According to Torah?

What Does the Text Actually Say?

Barn Scribe Opening

We have spent a long time asking who is Israel?

Now Moses takes us somewhere that may help sharpen that question.

In Deuteronomy 4, he speaks to Israel about statutes, judgments, wisdom, understanding, and the way the nations will look at them.

That gets my attention.

Because Moses does not simply call Israel a great nation and move on. He connects that greatness with something.

So before we decide what makes Israel great, I think we need to slow down and listen to how Moses says it.

Not how nations usually measure greatness.

Not how religion measures it.

How Torah measures it.

And maybe that will give us another piece of the answer we have been chasing.

The Text

Deuteronomy 4:1–8

“And now, O Israel, hearken unto the statutes and unto the ordinances, which I teach you, to do them; that ye may live, and go in and possess the land which YHWH, the God of your fathers, giveth you.

Ye shall not add unto the word which I command you, neither shall ye diminish from it, that ye may keep the commandments of YHWH your God which I command you.

Your eyes have seen what YHWH did in Baal-peor; for all the men that followed the Baal of Peor, YHWH thy God hath destroyed them from the midst of thee.

But ye that did cleave unto YHWH your God are alive every one of you this day.

Behold, I have taught you statutes and ordinances, even as YHWH my God commanded me, that ye should do so in the midst of the land whither ye go in to possess it.

Observe therefore and do them; for this is your wisdom and your understanding in the sight of the peoples, that, when they hear all these statutes, shall say: ‘Surely this great nation is a wise and understanding people.’

For what great nation is there, that hath God so nigh unto them, as YHWH our God is whensoever we call upon Him?

And what great nation is there, that hath statutes and ordinances so righteous as all this law, which I set before you this day?”

What Is Set Forward

Moses has spent the opening chapters looking backward. He has reminded Israel where they have been, what happened when they refused to trust YHWH, what happened when they tried to move without Him, and what happened when YHWH actually gave them the way forward.

Then chapter 4 turns with those words:

“And now, O Israel…”

That makes me want to slow down before I get any farther.

Moses is not speaking to people with no history. The people listening to him are carrying the consequences of what came before, and now he tells them to hearken to the statutes and ordinances he is teaching them “to do them.”

Not simply to know them.

Not simply to preserve them.

To do them.

And Moses connects that hearing and doing with life and with entering the land YHWH is giving them. Then, almost immediately, he gives them another boundary: do not add to the word and do not take away from it.

That sounds familiar around this barn.

But then Moses brings Baal-peor into the conversation. Some followed Baal-peor and were destroyed, while those who cleaved unto YHWH were alive that day. So by the time Moses gets to Israel’s wisdom before the nations, he has already put obedience, faithfulness, and consequence right in front of us.

Then comes the part that answers the question of this page.

The nations are going to see Israel’s statutes and ordinances and say, “Surely this great nation is a wise and understanding people.”

Moses does not point to the size of Israel’s army.

He does not point to its wealth.

He does not point to its ancestry by itself.

He points to the way this people hears and lives under what YHWH has given them, to the nearness of YHWH when they call upon Him, and to the righteousness of the statutes and ordinances set before them.

So when Torah speaks here of a great nation, greatness has already been given some boundaries of its own.

And I think we need to sit with those before we decide we know what makes Israel great.

What Is Observed

What I notice here is that Moses keeps tying Israel’s greatness to things that are very easy to overlook if we are in a hurry.

He tells them to hear the statutes and ordinances, but not just to hear them. They are to do them. He warns them not to add to the word and not to take away from it. Then he reminds them of Baal-peor, where some followed another way and were destroyed, while those who cleaved to YHWH were still alive.

That makes the later words about wisdom and greatness land differently for me.

Israel is not called great here because of size, bloodline, military strength, or how impressive they might look to the nations. The nations are supposed to see something in the way Israel lives under YHWH’s instruction.

They hear the statutes and ordinances and say, “Surely this great nation is a wise and understanding people.”

And then Moses gives two reasons that stand right beside that statement: YHWH is near when Israel calls upon Him, and the statutes and ordinances He has given are righteous.

That is a very different picture of greatness than the one people usually reach for.

The more I sit with it, the more it looks like Israel’s greatness is not something they manufacture for themselves.

It comes from YHWH being near and from Israel living under what He has given them.

And that brings us right back to the question we have been carrying all along: who is Israel?

Who is Israel?

But I am going to let Moses keep talking before I try to answer it.

What Is Revealed

What this passage begins to reveal is that Israel’s greatness is not being measured the way people usually measure greatness.

Moses is not talking about how many people Israel has, how much land they control, how strong their army is, or how impressive they look beside the nations around them. He keeps bringing the conversation back to something much simpler.

Hear what YHWH has given you.

Do it.

Do not add to it.

Do not take away from it.

And stay close to Him.

That is the picture sitting in front of us.

The nations are supposed to look at Israel and see wisdom and understanding because of the way Israel lives under YHWH’s statutes and ordinances. They are also supposed to notice something else: Israel has a God who is near when they call upon Him.

That gives the word great a very different feel.

Israel is not great because Israel has made itself great.

Israel is great because YHWH is near, His instruction is righteous, and the people are called to actually live according to it.

And that brings us right back to the question we have been carrying all along: who is Israel?

I am going to let Moses keep talking before I try to answer it.

What Is Established

By the time we reach the end of this passage, I think Moses has made one thing pretty plain.

Israel’s greatness is not being measured by the things people usually use to measure greatness.

Moses ties it to hearing YHWH’s statutes and ordinances, doing them, refusing to add to or take away from what He has given, and remaining close to Him.

That is what the nations are supposed to see.

They are supposed to see wisdom and understanding in the way Israel lives. They are supposed to see that YHWH is near when Israel calls upon Him. And they are supposed to see that the statutes and ordinances He has given are righteous.

So when Moses speaks of a great nation, the greatness is not coming from Israel making a name for itself.

It is coming from the relationship between YHWH and His people, and from the way those people live under what He has given them.

That does not answer every part of “Who is Israel?”

But it does give us something solid to stand on.

Whatever else we eventually learn about Israel, Torah does not separate Israel’s identity from the way Israel is called to live before YHWH.

Barn Scribe Closing

We started this page asking what makes Israel a great nation according to Torah.

Moses has answered that more clearly than I expected.

Israel is not great here because of size, strength, land, wealth, or reputation. Moses points us somewhere else entirely.

He points us to YHWH being near.

He points us to righteous statutes and ordinances.

He points us to a people who are supposed to hear those words, do them, and refuse to add to or take away from what YHWH has given.

That is the picture sitting in front of us.

And after walking through all these pages asking who is Israel?, I keep noticing that Torah will not let me separate identity from the way Israel is called to live.

The family line is still there.

The covenant is still there.

The stranger questions are still there.

None of that has disappeared.

But here in Deuteronomy 4, Moses makes something very plain: when the nations look at Israel and call them wise, understanding, and great, they are supposed to be seeing the result of a people living under YHWH’s instruction.

That gives me something solid to carry forward.

And maybe it also gives the old preacher a little less room to make greatness mean whatever he wants it to mean.

We are still asking who is Israel?

But the answer is getting harder to separate from this:

How does Israel live before YHWH?

That seems worth carrying with us.

Turn the page. ☕📜